Temp:64°

Local prison slated to close. Can any jobs be saved? Wednesday on Your Morning News.

Social media evidence being used in court

By Josh Gauntt, Reporter
Last Updated:
i-Poll
11111111-1111-1111-1111-111111111111

Should social media evidence be considered valid in court cases?

Yes, it's just as valid as paper records (29%)
No, it opens up room for fraud (31%)
It depends on the circumstance (40%)
View all recent polls

Last week when Rachel Wade was convicted of second-degree murder in the stabbing death of Sarah Ludemann, evidence was used from social networking websites.

Perhaps it’s a sign of the times that MySpace and Facebook messages, photos, and status updates are being used against people in court.

Tweets on Twitter are even being used to lock up defendants.

Ryan Rooth, with the Rooth Law Group in St. Petersburg, said he uses social networking messages in court if they will prove a motive.

"If there's a sense of postings that shows dislike toward a person, or in the case of Rachel Wade, when there's a comment she would kill the other person,” said Rooth. “It can be used against her to show not only motive, but also they had an intent to commit a crime."

Prosecutors in the Wade case said she sent Ludemann several nasty Facebook messages threatening her life.

Ultimately, she did.

In the past, Rooth said he has even used MySpace messages to prove that one of his clients was innocent.

"I used it as a defense tool to show that a victim of a particular battery charge was lying and it proved to be very successful," said Rooth.

What people may not realize is that there’s an online electronic trail following them every click of the way.

"Common sense is key,” said Rooth. “Don't put anything online that you'll be embarrassed of."

Attorneys need a subpoena or a court order to access an individual’s computer.

If police and law enforcement agencies have probable cause, they can search computers without those two items.

Post a comment

Comments

You must enable Javscript for comments to function.

POSTING PROCESS: Comments will appear on the page within 10 minutes of a submission. There is a 400 character limitation to each post and comments will be held to this restriction. If you see a post you feel violates the posting policy please click on Report this post for a staff member to review.

POSTING POLICY: Vulgar, obscene, and offensive language will not be tolerated. Anyone who uses such language in their post will not be allowed to participate in future comments. While we value freedom of speech, we also wish to protect our visitors from exposure to inflammatory content. Thank you.

COMMENTS BY USERS ARE NOT ENDORSED BY SERVICE PROVIDER: You can access the User Agreement at any time. Your use of and/or registration on any aspect of the Service will constitute your agreement to comply with these rules.

Hernando authorities raid home, find underground tunnel

Email
Email

Cell Phone
Cell Phone

Desktop
Desktop

Get news and weather alerts delivered directly to your desktop, cell phone or email with the Bay News 9 News Alert system, Bay News 9 Now.

Bay News 9 profiles people making a positive difference in the Bay area community and beyond.

Do you know someone who should be an Everyday Hero?  Let us know!

Get the latest weather

Get the most up-to-date forecast from Bay News 9's Weather Experts.

 
Bay News 9 Partners
Bay News 9 Infomas Bright House Sports Network News 13
Tampa Bay On Demand Bright House Networks St. Petersburg Times
Road Runner Tampa Bay Business Journal CNN.com
The Ledger Bradenton Herold Citrus Chronicle