Pennsylvania, Michigan crucial to fall election

Saturday, August 30, 2008

Republican presidential candidate Sen. John McCain, R-Ariz., talks with voters outside Tom's Diner with his wife Cindy, center, and his vice presidential running mate, Alaska Gov., Sarah Palin, right, in Pittsburgh, Pa., Saturday morning, Aug. 30, 2008. Palin's daughter, Piper, stands next to her. (AP Photo/Stephan Savoia)

By CHARLES BABINGTON
BEAVER, Pa. (AP) -- Keep your eyes on Pennsylvania and Michigan.

There are battleground states in the presidential election, and then there are these two, looming larger than all others because they offer such a rich opportunity for Republican John McCain and potential peril for Democrat Barack Obama.

If McCain carries either one, he could lose several states that President Bush won and still claim the White House. For Obama, a loss in either would put him in a deep hole, forcing him to win numerous states that have voted Republican in recent elections to have any hope of prevailing on Nov. 4.

It's no coincidence that Obama and his running mate, Delaware Sen. Joe Biden, made Pennsylvania their first stop Friday after leaving their party's convention in Denver, with several Michigan stops scheduled for Sunday. McCain and his new running mate, Alaska Gov. Sarah Palin, held a rally Saturday in Washington, Pa., and they have promised to visit both states repeatedly.

There are plenty of other vigorously contested states: Florida, Ohio, Missouri, Colorado and Virginia, to name a few. But Michigan and Pennsylvania are different.

John Kerry and Al Gore carried both in their losing campaigns in 2000 and 2004. So they form an almost must-win minimum for Obama. He would start with the base those two men had, and then try to pick up enough Bush-carried states to put him over the top.

What worries Obama, and gives McCain hope, is that both states have hundreds of thousands of white, mostly working-class Democrats who seem wary of Obama. In the Pennsylvania primary they gave Hillary Rodham Clinton a big win over Obama, and now McCain is wooing them hard.

They're being told by Obama's people that their personal and political interests should trump any qualms about voting for a black man in his first Senate term.

Polls show Obama slightly ahead in both states, but McCain may be within striking distance.

To be elected, Obama must win 18 more electoral votes than Kerry did four years ago. If he loses Pennsylvania, his deficit jumps to 39 electoral votes. If he loses Michigan instead, the gap is 35.

Those are big numbers, because the Bush-won states that look most promising for Obama tend to be small, with few electoral votes.

The possibilities and math can get complicated.

Suppose Obama carried every state that Kerry did, including Michigan and Pennsylvania, and then added Bush's states of Iowa, New Mexico and Nevada all prime targets this year. He'd still lose to McCain.

But if he grabbed one more state that Kerry lost _ Colorado, for instance _ then he would be president.

McCain, on the other hand, could lose Ohio or Florida (both won by Bush in 2000 and 2004) and essentially offset it with a win in Michigan or Pennsylvania. Swapping Florida for Michigan would cost McCain 10 net electoral votes, but he'd still win the election if all other states followed 2004 results.

Obama's challenge becomes far greater if he loses either Pennsylvania or Michigan. Even if he won all the other Kerry states from 2004 and added the Bush states of New Mexico, Nevada, Colorado, Iowa and Virginia _ a state with 13 electoral votes that Democrats haven't won in decades _ he would lose the election.

"I need Pennsylvania," Obama told a crowd of several thousand at an outdoor rally in Beaver on Friday night. "I need Beaver, Pennsylvania. I need you to stand up beside me and say now is the time to bring about change in America."

In the crowd, Kim Stelmach of Pittsburgh cheered, and fretted a bit. Despite having young twins at home, she finds time to volunteer for Obama, and is well aware that Pennsylvania is a must-win state.

She said she is confident that the vast majority of women who voted for Clinton will be with Obama this fall. "I think it's a myth that they have all this anger," she said.

But when it comes to white working-class Democrats, she said, "I'm extremely nervous. That's why I'm volunteering."

She and her husband, Russell, a self-employed window contractor, said they hear numerous misgivings about Obama from blue-collar friends and during the door-knocking Kim does for the campaign. Russell Stelmach said we was less enthusiastic about Obama, but he strongly backs Biden, who was born in Scranton.

Michigan and Pennsylvania have been hit hard by the long decline in heavy manufacturing jobs, especially in the steel and auto industries. Obama tells workers (and unemployed people) that Republicans have abandoned them. He promises to invest in technologies that will create jobs, and to cut middle-class taxes to help families pay their bills.

McCain also promises to bring more jobs to the heartland. He places more emphasis on across-the-board tax cuts and greater flexibility in finding health insurance.

Both men will spend ample time in other battleground states, which pose different challenges. Obama could wipe out Kerry's 18 electoral vote deficit with a win in either Ohio or Florida, which Gore and Kerry lost, if no other states switched from the 2004 results. Polls show McCain slightly ahead in those states.

While Obama would love to pick off Ohio or Florida, his strategy seems tilted more to grabbing a handful of smaller states that Kerry lost, including Iowa, Nevada, New Mexico and Colorado. That approach makes it essential that he win Michigan and Pennsylvania.

Like Pennsylvania, Michigan has thousands of white working-class voters who call themselves Democrats but sometimes vote Republican.

Obama did not campaign in Michigan during the primary because a Democratic Party dispute essentially negated the state's primary election. He needs to make up for lost time, says Michigan Gov. Jennifer Granholm.

He needs to "come, come, come to Michigan," she said. The state's wary voters, she said, need "to feel him, see him, touch him."

McCain, too, would love nothing better than to win them over, which could give him a victory in Michigan and a huge step toward the White House.